[TyboeThePuma]

Id have to say it would be near a tie. There are so many more free players than members. Consider how amny noob accounts, pures, and othr characters that a klot of members have. I have like 5 account, only one of which is a member(my main. I also have a miner, and like three noob pkers). The free players would outnumber p2p by great amounts. Now the members, they have an advantage because of their stats and gear. Members are higher leveled and have better weapons/spells/armor/stats in general. They would have the advantage in battle. I couldnt say who would win.

[Goto]

Heh, i'm one of those red people with a dragon axe i think. The thing you have to take into account is presumably this would be a wilderness battle and f2p has nearly ALL the pures and pkers (often the people have mains on p2p). I know a high level impure can win by using magic against a pure, but with the sheer number of people who pk on free it could be quite a close fight.

[CongressJon]

F2p does have more pures though... But still, level can beat purity, and that counts for a lot.

[Crescens]

A lot of us F2P people play on the free servers because we don't have time to play often enough to pay for it. Yeah, the P2P people would probably own us completely because most of us are level 3 noobs. Keep in mind that people on the P2P servers generally play a lot more, and are thus definitely going to be at much higher levels, regardless.

NOTE: By level 3 noobs, that was in self-mockery of the fact that I only played the game once and never bothered to play again. It was not intended to flame anyone.

[vietpryde]

tie. p2p does have lvl 123's BUT how will they attack us in the wild? :O hehehehe.

[obiwan22]

The 123's would eliminate all the high lvl f2p's (lvl 70-110) and then us middle levels would kill ya.

[vietpryde]

[Traver]

This completely depends on a lot of factors. Where will it be held? If no special servers were made, it HAVE to be on a free server, thus eliminating all advantages the members would've had (better potions, better arrows, dragon weapons and so forth), because members can't use them on free servers. So it would practically be f2p vs f2p, anyway. However, if JAGeX made some special server just for this occasion, I am pretty sure that p2p would win, considering they have Iban Blast, those three new spells, better potions, better arrows and better armour/weapons.

Also, for the part about f2p housing a lot of pures, that is true. However, a lot of these pures have a main which is p2p. So it will also depend on what character these people will choose (their pure or their main).

This post has been edited by Traver: 14 October 2003 - 12:10 PM

[Spikeout]

It will be held in an arena where everyone can attack each other

[Bodom]

this would be a good idea, i think jagex should make a member world available to all but take all the fishing mining thieving etc stuff away and npc things and let f2p and p2p set out in a viscous battle with no food and once u die u r out of it! and its until there is no more p2p or f2p players left but only a max of 600f2p and 500p2p could take part say, because p2p obviously have an advantage.