[Stargate3216]

Heres what would happen. First you make it p2p, then you make it so when you pking theres an option to manually fight players or monsters. To keep it fair, youy amke it so that you coyld only fight people manually who are on manual them selfs.

BTW i know seed oveously can make changes to rs (for people who take stuff ilterally). I used "you" to replace jagex and players.

[©allum]

Manual fighting? Like 'a' is attack and 'b' is block?


No,no,no,no,no.....

[Ratty]

No,no,no,no,no.....

[Bodom]

I just dunno what your going on about

[Goto]

Hmm.. while it would liven up the combat system considerably, Runescape was designed for the system it has. It would be pretty much impossible to actually get it right without rewriting all of Runescape. Most RPGs like Runescape have a similar type of combat, because it works well for the type of game.

[Hax the Cook]

there goes all use for bonuses.....

I say NO.

[Raevn Kite]

AGGHHHH!! Srry for the harshness but... AGGHHHH!! NO. That would really mess up combat, S.P attacks and everything.

[Bodom]

Oh i get it now, wouldnt work, i mean what you gonna do, left click to swing and right click to block... so much difference there

[Stargate3216]

No lvls would still matter. (Defence for how many hits u take and Attack and str (combind them?) for the hits you deal. I think it would be just moving the mouse to block, left click to slash, and right click to stab. But lvls and armor would still play a huge part in it. A lvl 30 couldn't beat a lvl 45 no matter how stilled the person was (if they had equal armor and weapons). REMEBER: p2p only and u could only fight manual against manual people.

[Goto]

Hmm.. The only way I could see this working is possibly as some arena minigame thing on members. That way it wouldn't really matter if it messed up regular gameplay, it'd just be for a bit of fun.

[Stargate3216]

Ya, i think their should be certain worlds (2 or 3) where you could pk manually.

[Raevn Kite]

like a duel arena kind of thing? i see it....

[Kimojuno]

I do not like the original idea but I like having like a type of arena, this would be a good idea, although manual fighting has been suggested before so not sure if they would do it now, but I do not like how you say only certain worlds any members worlds (lets face it doubt it's going to be members) but not in wilderness just a special arena set aside (heck they could even throw it into the new pyramid updates like a special desert arena) hehe -- anyway just my inputs.

~ Kimojuno

[superchao]

N0

[Mobster101]

even though i don't like turn based stuff, that sounds dumb...kinda....
EDIT:

gothicness pwns!

squishy your a goth?

This post has been edited by Mobster101: 05 April 2005 - 03:30 PM