Okay, well, I'm just going to shortly insert my opinion into here.

First off: I understand that you like Ms. #2, but for you to actually try to go out with her is an incredibly stupid move. I'd suggest remaining good friends (or very good friends, however you want to put it) for as long as you can, really. Unless she breaks up with her boyfriend, or she starts making any moves toward you, do not do anything. Sure, maybe flirt a bit, but, well... Nothing to much.
Holy crap....maybe #1 does like me....ohh $#!%....
That may not be such a bad thing as you think. The way you put it, she's a relaly good person. That's not to say that #2 isn't, but, well, it seems like a very big reason you are unattracted to her is because she's not as good looking as #2. Just remember this - LOOKS AREN'T EVERYTHING.
Of course, my advice may, at any point, explode. So don't necessarily follow it.
What hyper meens is friends with privlages
